Skip to main content

Not-so-green situation

Published June 05. 2019 01:32PM

This paper has reported much about the Broad Mountain Wind Farm project. Reports of recent public hearings reflect the concerns of residents of the area involved in this project. They have expressed concerns about effects on wildlife, degradation of the area’s natural beauty, and potential interference with TV signals. While the project manager for Broad Mountain Wind Farm said this project brings no significant impact to human health or the environment, that is not entirely accurate. Although most wind turbine parts, including the foundation, tower and components of the gearbox and generator are recyclable, the turbine blades, which make up only 2% to 3% of the mass of an entire structure, are another story.

Most turbine blades are made from composites. Older blades were made using glass fiber, while more recent models are made using carbon fiber. The composite is designed for peak aerodynamic performance and lightweight durability, but it is not designed for recycling. Since there is no proven recycling solution, research groups and wind energy associations around the world have predicted that wind turbine blades will generate nearly 50,000 tons of waste in 2020. This is forecast to rise to 200,000 to 225,000 tons of waste by 2034.

Finding ways to make the blades usable again, or convert them to some other usable material is a major challenge. Thus, increased use of this “green” energy alternative has caused a not-so-green situation. Although promoted as a solution to global climate change, wind turbines do not remain “green” to the end. One compelling question must be answered by those considering the wind farm for the Broad Mountain: Does adding to the global trash crisis really improve the environment?

JoAnn Paslawsky

Tamaqua

Comments
Warren Buffet, the Omaha billionaire investor, is quoted as telling an audience in Omaha, Nebraska, recently, “For example, on wind energy, we get a tax credit if we build a lot of wind farms. That’s the only reason to build them. They don’t make sense without the tax credit.” It sounds like Mr. Buffett gets it!
My two cents... Wind isn't very reliable.
That quote is over 5 years old, not recent, and the context was around why Berkshire Hathaway invests in wind farms when there are higher margin investments they could make. His point was not that wind is something we shouldn't be doing, it was that the subsidies are a tax hedge for him that makes up for the lower margin.

Buffett also has controlling interest of MiddleAmerica which will be a 100% renewable energy company by 2020. I doubt he would be investing if he thought it was a bad energy source.
Wow! Read Much?
It's a lousy energy source for Pennsylvania, and that's what we are talking about. This isn't Nebraska.
And it's only considered when you throw in the subsidies. Go back and read what he was saying. Just to set things straight... you and others helped pay for my hybridized solar domestic hot water heating system. Thanks, it provided us not only hotter, free water, but you all helped me buy it.
I and Warren a smart. Thanks again chump.
Feeling that Christian love...

I’m pointing out you lie in your post and the context. What you don’t get is that the fossil fuel industry gets billions on billions of subsidy and support from the federal government, far more than turbines. We need to be focused on clean renewables or we will destroy Gods creation.
Come on Joe, you are one of the biggest frauds around. If you accuse Meyers of being a liar, just remember when you point a finger there are three fingers pointing back at you. You, Joe, are a fraud to yourself when you refuse to see any sources that would answer your false accusations of President Trump. Are you afraid of the truth? Or, has Trump Derangement Syndrome affected your mind? You are a self proclaimed genius...that is stupid,...a libertarian...that is a liberal,...a financial expert...that doesn’t notice the greatest economy since 1969,...a Doctoral want to be...without an advanced degree. A Pious...hater of Christianity,...a military expert...that had some cousins in the military,...a Patriot...that always sides with the enemy, a citizen...that does opposition research on other citizens,...a scholar...that refuses information. Bipolar much, Joe? You are a condescending fraud. Keep it up.
Come on Joe. The fossil fuel industry, as you say, ( I say the petroleum industry) is thousands of times larger than the minuscule wind turbine industry. Thus the difference in subsidies. Isn’t it great that America is finally energy independent? Isn’t it great that President Obama didn’t choke energy to death, before President Trump resurrected and rebuilt it to record levels? Isn’t it great that President Trump doesn’t legislate renewable energy before the ability is achieved? Isn’t it great that you, Joe, give President Trump credit for his many achievements across the energy spectrum? I am pointing out that you are a fraud Joe. What you don’t get is that you lie in your posts & content. You are a half wit.
I lied? What?
Subsidized anything is wrong, but at least atomic, coal, gas, and oil, work when needed, you can't say that about wind or solar. Remember, I own solar. Now how did I lie?

Classified Ads

Event Calendar

<<

April 2025

>>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
  
   

Upcoming Events

Twitter Feed